 |
June 1,
2003
By Marc Minardi & Dennis Edelman
Opening (Denny)
Thanks Penny for the opportunity to speak this morning.
This is not meant to be a sermon per se, but more of an opportunity to
tell our story of transformation at MCCSF.
Today, June 1, is our 20th anniversary of the day when we first arrived
at MCC.
What Newness Looks Like (Marc)
Many of us may think of the 34th anniversary of Stonewall, which we will
be celebrating in a few weeks, as a removed or distant historical event.
For Denny and I, who lived as a couple through Stonewall, the significance
of that event, in a place not more than 20 feet from Herald Square where
I played as a child, changed our lives dramatically.
Before Stonewall, there were very few examples of gay couples in the media,
not to mention a "gay liberation movement." Fear of being discovered,
led Gay and lesbian people to be isolated from one another and not well
connected as a community. We knew there were bars where you could go to
meet other people, but generally these were cruising places and not places
where friendships could be developed or serious relationships formed.
Stonewall, however, made all things new. For Denny and I, it let us know
community was possible. That gay people didn't have to tow a straight line
to be themselves.
Just a year before Stonewall in 1968, Denny and I were concluding our
final year at Princeton Seminary where we met. The Seminary had discovered
that I was gay and required that I see a psychiatrist to cure me of my "deviant" behavior
before I could graduate. Needless to say, I had to keep my relationship
with Denny secret. During my therapy sessions, the psychiatrist told me
that by the time I was 40 I would find gay relationships impermanent and
I would wind up being a lonely old man. I am glad that after Stonewall,
I had the foresight to reject that advice and reaffirm my relationship
with Denny. It was the best decision I ever made in my life!
This morning's reading is by Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a Lutheran theologian
who was imprisoned by the Nazis for suspicion of conspiring to assassinate
Adolf Hitler. Bonhoeffer was a profound moral thinker who believed that
the price of personal and spiritual freedom involved integrity and commitment
to action. As the Nazis began to discover more and more about his own personal
involvement in the plot, Bonhoeffer's days in prison became darker and
more ominous. The Second Lesson describes how Bonhoeffer saw the Church
of his time - weak and undermined by Nazi forces, and incapable of speaking
any message of relevance to society. Bonhoeffer saw a need for a truly
new church, invoking new spiritual language along with the theme of personal
liberation. As a prisoner, he imagined how the release from bondage (physical
freedom, societal repression?, addictions? homophobia?) could transform
human beings and give them great power.
Personal liberation is amazing stuff and it mirrors exactly how Denny
and I felt during those first years at MCC. It was the thrill of being
at a place that puts no barriers between one's gay or lesbian life and
spirituality, and requires us to exercise our faith with passion, and live
out spirituality in community.
Community at MCC (Denny)
When we arrived at MCC we found ourselves encircled by community in ways
we had never experienced before.
We found ourselves encircled by others wanting to hear our story and eager
to tell us theirs. By the first few weeks at MCC, we were assigned to a
neighborhood MCC social group. Here we heard incredible life stories of
joy and tragedy and ultimate gay transformation. It was in this group that
we connected with Lynn Jordan and Richard O'Dell and others from the church
that have been friends now for 20 years. It was all very good.
We found ourselves in circles of friends who shared common interests
in theatre, music, movies and dance. Bob Havens and Jim McRae invited
us to join the Theater Rhino Group, which has continued to the present
day.
We found ourselves involved in political activism. Michael Denton, a firebrand
Democrat, involved us in the Alice B. Toklas Club. Through MCC, and through
Alice, we participated in the election of many qualified gay officials
and passed gay positive propositions that led to furthering the progressive
movement in this City.
We found ourselves communicating more with the larger community of our
families, old friends and colleagues at work about our lives and how they
were changing.
In short, the church formed our civic, cultural, social and spiritual
life where today all that we do and all whom we know in OZ was connected
through MCC. We are amazed at the community the Church surrounds us with
today.
Our Coming Out Letter (Marc)
In 1988, after 5 years of sensational life in San Francisco and at MCCSF,
the changes happening in each of us during the period could no longer be
contained. We decided to write a letter to our classmates at Seminary about
what happened to us. It was a major coming out for us. Here is a portion
of that letter:
"Dear Friends,
It is hard to believe that twenty years have passed since we have seen
one another. Our plans are not firm as yet as to a possible trip to Princeton
for our reunion, so if it does not come off, we wanted to take this means
to communicate to you our friends who knew us during those tumultuous
years of the sixties and send our greetings and best wishes as you gather."
The letter goes on to describe what we were doing up until that time and
then continues…
"Gradually, however the pressures of work and a desire for change
began to grip us. We experienced the joys of Fire Island following Stonewall,
and what the potential of gay community could be like. Having known no
gay people in New Jersey, it triggered contrasts that we began to think
about more and more as the years passed. Even regular trips overseas did
not help to ameliorate the sense that we were missing something very important
in our life.
The opportunity for Marc to transfer to Berkeley opened and we both seized
upon it as a chance to start again, this time focusing on gay relationships
as a key objective to what we wanted. Unchurched during this time (the
rejection of the Presbyterian Church's recommendations on homosexuality
proved to be the last straw for us), we happened upon the Metropolitan
Community Church of San Francisco one Sunday in June. We loved it and haven't
missed a Sunday since. Our church has proven to be a haven for former clergy,
but laity exercise profound and talented leadership and we see ourselves
as supporters and contributors to this process. With the homeless, poor,
disenfranchised and AIDS, there is a great deal that needs doing in this
City. We have made intense and deep friendships during this time working
on these problems and have found a level of spiritual commitment to each
other and to our friends that we never anticipated or thought possible
in this age. We really feel ourselves part of something new that reminds
us most of what New Testament Christianity is all about."
This letter, I think, puts into context what has happened to us since
we arrived in San Francisco and at this church in particular. We didn't
know it then, but the "something new" we were looking for resulted
in new energy between each of us, new understandings about our relationship
with our Higher Power, new dynamics in friendship, new social and political
commitments and new ways of exploring the great possibilities of life.
The Significance of APS (Denny)
Some of you may have heard one of us say to the other inexplicably "APS."
Long before Stonewall, in the midst of a Presbyterian Seminary education,
beginning in 1965 Marc and I shared a growing commitment for one another.
It was impossible to speak of it anywhere. During these years we were studying
classical Greek and Hebrew languages together. Out of those studies during
that first year or two in school we developed a secret code word to express
at any time our growing love and commitment for one another. That code
word was "APS."
It comes from the Greek for "I love you".
Although the
need for secret codes has long past in our lives, we continue to use
it affectionately
daily. Over the years it has increased in meaning
for us since only we knew of it then, it protected us for a long time,
allowed for important communication between us and today it carries
the added treasures from each of the last 37 years together. The point
is
- however - it developed out of our religious training and was transformed
to something new and spiritual between us.
Ceremonies and Symbols at MCC (Marc)
As former history majors, Denny and I have always been interested in the
way events are connected to each other, what themes can be distilled, and
how we can improve our life experience based on what has gone before. So
it is natural that both of us would gravitate toward politics, Denny toward
domestic issues and me toward international concerns.
We both have taken an interest in symbols as well - me through hobbies
such as flag and beer label collecting, Denny through more symbolic thinking
by connecting the dots toward political strategizing.
For us, ceremonies and symbols are important. They serve as markers and
measures of roads traveled (or not). That's why we felt it important to
share with you our anniversary today of 20 years at this marvelous place.
We look back at all those who have gone before, both living and deceased.
We celebrate clergy who have had an impact on us: Michael England, Janie
Spahr, Rick Wetherly, Michael McManus, Kit Cherry, Conni Staff, Dan Geslin,
Jim Mitulski, Karen Foster, Jim Glyer, Bill Lowell and of course current
clergy and staff, Penny, Terri, Lea, Paul, Joe and Eric and Steve.
We celebrate friendships we have made here, among them Carlene Ames, Tim
Babbage, Glen Baker, Don Bradley, Greg Brown, Michael Berry, Les and Diane
Brabetz, Richard Brabham, Lloyd Burton, John Calabrese, Don Chambers, John
Cortez, Bob Crocker, Georgia Davis, Richard Davis, Gordan Deegan, Virgil
Dixon, Kevin Fong, Robert Geibert, Jan Gerritsen, Michael Gilbert, Charles
Gohmann, Tovah Green, Michael Haigler, Harry Harkness, Patrick Horay, Bob
Havens, Jack Hubbs, Kathryn Hetzner, Ken Ho, Peter Ho, Paul Holton, Jim
Huey, Ted Johnson, Herb Levy, John Lira, Lynn Jordan, Greg Jurin, Diane
Kalliam, Bob Lawrence, Carl Lawrence, Earline Leppert, Audrey Lockwood,
Michael MacRae, Jim McCrea, Max Mason, Drew Metcalfe, Ross Morgan, Hal
Nathan, Fran Peavey, Sylvia Perez, John Pritz, John Ribaudo, Jeff Robinson,
Michael Robinson, Gail Seneca, Jim Sizemore, Bonnie Smith, Dan Smith, Pierre
Sollier, Paul Stratton, Yew-hoe Tan, Linton Stables, Ken Theriault, Roger
Tinsman, Ken Tipton, Cees van Aalst, George Voigt, Steve Warren, Scott
Weldon, Edward Wu, Brad Yost and many others too numerous to name, but
with a history of many memorable moments shared together.
We remember loved ones who have been a part of this place and passed on:
Fred Reeves, Kurt Stutzman, Bill Knox, James Sandmire, Scott Johnson, Rick
Wetherly, Wayne Mielke, Richard O'dell, Ric Hand, Michael Denton, Paul
Francis, Nicholas Carter, Howard Wells, Les Bates, Ron Russell Coons, Patrick
Sigfried, Shelby Topp, Michael Redding, Greg Wherry, Bruce Bunger, Scott
Galuteria, Roger Spiecher, Floyd Ohler, Roberto Galindo, David Castagna,
Jesse Odin, Joel Payne, Doug Wolfe, Cory Lowther, Jeff Alons, Bill Pugh,
Enrique Bragayrac, Sam Blazer and Margaret Minardi among many, many others.
And finally, we note events in the life of our church which were important
firsts:
The Membership Committee of the National Council of Churches takes
communion, their first time together, and in our church!
Passage of California's first major domestic partners legislation is celebrated
by a marriage ceremony (including ours) at a morning service.
Our first successful capital drive resulting in the installation of our
church organ.
Our first major estate gift by Chuck Rozema, which enabled us to own our
own building and pave the way for future financial viability.
The beginning of Q-Sangha that allows us to broaden our ministry and make
us truly "a house of prayer for all people."
The decision by this congregation, after years of discussion, to commit
to a new church building.
Continuing Newness and Surprise (Denny)
Everything about this church is new!
Church is fun. Within reason we can do anything here without judgments.
It is outrageous with colors and décor.
It is constantly changing in appearance.
A conservative religion made truly liberal.
God is no longer male, but female or maybe both?
Communion is not ours but ours and everyone else's.
Hymns have new and exciting texts and we actually sing them!
Music is inclusive as is everything.
Deaths, many deaths, over many, many years are transformed into life.
A Christ found in Buddha, in Allah, in Abraham, in other spiritualities
and in you, too, and vice- versa.
2000 years ago Paul wrote to the Corinthians "so…in Christ…everything
old has passed away, see, everything has become new."
60 years ago Bonhoeffer wrote to the infant, "the new church will
have a new language, perhaps quite non-religious, but liberating and redeeming."
18 years ago Marc and I wrote to our classmates "we really felt ourselves
part of something new that reminds us most of what New Testament Christianity
is about."
On our first Sunday here 20 years ago today, you baptized us into a very
new idea of faith and community. It is amazing that MCC is as new and exciting
to us today as it was during those first intoxicating months here in 1983.
We love you!
|